
There’s a long tradition of explaining the transformation of democracy into authoritarianism as the story of “too much democracy” enabling the rise of a demagogue who makes himself a tyrant. It is “too much democracy” in that the rise of the demagogue is the consequence of a decline in authority and a flattening of hierarchy. In this talk I want to focus on two relatively recent examples of that narrative (more recent that Plato or Plutarch, anyway), one because it was influential (Samuel Huntington’s chapter in the 1975 Trilateral Commission report “Crisis of Democracy”), and the other because it’s typical (Andrew Sullivan’s May 2016 “Democracies End When They Are Too Democratic”).


